Hamas wins the battle for Gaza, by Scott Ritter – NehalBlog

The not too long ago introduced ceasefire is a blessing for Palestinians and Israelis alike: an opportunity for prisoners to be exchanged, humanitarian assist for individuals who want it, and for feelings on either side of the battle to relax.

Though the ceasefire, brokered between Israel and Hamas by Qatar, was mutually agreed between the 2 sides, let nobody be fooled into considering that it was something lower than a victory of Hamas. Israel had adopted a very aggressive position that, given its acknowledged aim of destroying Hamas as a company, it could not comply with a ceasefire underneath any circumstances.

Hamas, for its half, has made the discharge of Palestinian prisoners, significantly girls and kids, held by Israel, considered one of its fundamental aims in launching the present spherical of combating with Israel. Seen on this mild, the ceasefire represents a big victory for Hamas and a humiliating defeat for Israel.

One of many causes Israel averted a ceasefire was that it was satisfied that the offensive operation it had launched northern Gaza would neutralize Hamas as a navy risk, and that any ceasefire, regardless of the humanitarian justification, would solely purchase time for Hamas’ defeated enemy to relaxation, reequip, and regroup. The truth that Israel signed a ceasefire is the surest signal that each one just isn’t properly within the Israeli offensive towards Hamas.

This end result mustn’t have stunned anybody. When Hamas launched its assault on Israel on October 7, it launched a plan years within the making. The meticulous consideration to element that was evident within the Hamas operation underscored the truth that Hamas had studied the Israeli intelligence and navy forces deployed towards it, revealing weaknesses that had been then exploited. Hamas’ motion represented far more than sound tactical and operational planning and execution: it was additionally a masterpiece of strategic conceptualization.

One of many fundamental causes for the Israeli defeat on October 7 was the Israeli authorities’s perception that Hamas won’t ever assault, no matter what the intelligence analysts chargeable for monitoring Hamas actions in Gaza had been saying. This lack of creativeness is because of the truth that Hamas has recognized the political objectives and aims of Israel (the cancellation of Hamas as a resistance group by enterprise a coverage based mostly on “shopping for” Hamas by way of an expanded program of labor permits issued by Israel to Palestinians dwelling in Israel). Gaza.) By enjoying with the work allow program, Hamas lulled Israeli leaders into complacency, permitting Hamas to organize its assault in plain sight.

The Hamas assault of October 7 was not an remoted operation, however somewhat a part of a strategic plan with three fundamental aims: to place the query of a Palestinian state again on the worldwide stage, to liberate the hundreds of Palestinian prisoners. held by Israel, and to drive Israel to stop and desist from desecrating the Al Aqsa Mosque, the third holiest web site in Islam. The assault of October 7, alone, didn’t obtain these outcomes. Quite, the October 7 assault was supposed to set off an Israeli response that might create the circumstances obligatory for Hamas’s objectives to be realized.

The October 7 assault was supposed to humiliate Israel to the purpose of irrationality, to make sure that any Israeli response can be ruled by an emotional want for revenge, versus a rational response designed to defeat Hamas’s objectives. Right here, Hamas was guided by the established Israeli doctrine of collective punishment (often called the Dahiya doctrine, named after the western suburbs of Beirut that had been closely bombed by Israel in 2006, with a purpose to punish the Lebanese folks for Israel’s failure to defeat Hezbollah in fight.) By inflicting on Israel a humiliating defeat that shattered each the parable of Israeli invincibility (with respect to the Israel Protection Forces) and infallibility (in the direction of Israeli intelligence), and taking a whole lot of Israelis hostage earlier than retreating into its territory. underground lair under GazaHamas set a entice for Israel into which, predictably, the federal government of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu rushed.

Hamas has ready a community of tunnels underneath the Gaza strip which, in whole, lengthen over greater than 500 kilometers. Dubbed “Gaza Metro,” these tunnels encompass interconnected deep underground bunkers used for command and management, logistical assist, medical care and cantonment, in addition to different tunnel networks devoted to defensive and offensive operations. The tunnels are buried deep sufficient to keep away from being destroyed by most of Israel’s bombs and have been designed to resist a siege of as much as three months (90 days).

Hamas is aware of it can not interact Israel in a conventional force-on-force confrontation. As an alternative, the aim was to lure Israeli forces into Gaza, then topic these forces to an infinite sequence of hit-and-run assaults by small groups of Hamas fighters who would emerge from their underground lairs, assault a weak Israeli drive, then disappear underground. In brief, subjecting the Israeli military to what quantities to loss of life by a thousand cuts.

And it labored. Though Israeli forces managed to penetrate the much less urbanized areas of the northern Gaza Strip, benefiting from the mobility and firepower of its armored troops, progress is illusory, as Hamas forces frequently harass Israelis, utilizing lethal tandem rockets to disable or destroy Israeli autos, killing dozens of Israeli troopers and injuring a whole lot extra. Whereas Israel has been reluctant to reveal the variety of armored autos misplaced on this method, Hamas says the quantity is within the a whole lot. Hamas’ claims are bolstered by the truth that Israel halted the sale of outdated Merkava 3 tanks and as an alternative organized its stock of those autos into new reserve armored battalions to compensate for the heavy losses suffered each in Gaza and alongside from the northern border. border with Lebanon, the place Hezbollah forces are engaged in a lethal struggle of attrition with Israel in operations to assist Hamas in Gaza.

However the principle motive for Israel’s defeat thus far is Israel itself. After taking the bait and falling into Hamas’s entice, Israel continued to hold out its Dahiya Doctrine towards the Palestinian inhabitants of Gaza, finishing up indiscriminate assaults towards civilian objects in blatant disregard for the legal guidelines of struggle. An estimated 13,000 Palestinian civilians had been killed in these assaults, together with greater than 5,000 youngsters. A number of thousand different victims stay buried underneath the rubble of their destroyed houses.

Though Israel was in a position to acquire worldwide assist following the October 7 Hamas assault, its blatant overreaction as an alternative turned international public opinion towards it – one thing Hamas was relying on. Right this moment, Israel is more and more remoted, shedding assist not solely within the so-called International South, but additionally in conventional strongholds of pro-Israel sentiment in the US, the UK and Europe. . This isolation, mixed with the kind of political stress Israel just isn’t accustomed to, contributed to the Netanyahu authorities’s acquiescence within the ceasefire and subsequent prisoner trade.

It stays to be seen whether or not the ceasefire will maintain or not. Likewise, the query of learn how to rework the ceasefire into an enduring cessation of hostilities stays an open query. However one factor is for certain: after having declared that victory is outlined by The total defeat of Hamasthe Israelis have set the stage for a Hamas victory, which Hamas achieves just by surviving.

However Hamas does greater than survive: it wins. After combating the Israeli Defense Forces Stalled on the battlefield, Hamas has seen every of its strategic aims on this battle come to fruition. The world is actively expressing absolutely the want for a two-state resolution as a prerequisite for lasting peace within the area. Palestinians detained by Israel are exchanged for Israelis taken hostage by Hamas. And the Islamic world is united in condemning Israel’s desecration of the Al Aqsa Mosque.

None of those points had been on the desk on October 6. That they’re resolved now could be a testomony to Hamas’s success on October 7, and within the days and weeks that adopted, as Israeli forces had been defeated due to Hamas’ tenacity. and their very own predilection for indiscriminate violence towards civilians. Removed from being eradicated as a navy and political drive, Hamas has turn out to be maybe essentially the most related voice and authority on the subject of defending the pursuits of the Palestinian folks.

Source link

Leave a Comment